1) The States do not have a good record of developing and maintaining such projects (including the Waterfront/Fort Regent).
2) Given the economic outlook, which is uncertain at best and given that other private developers are already building new grade A office space, it seems an overly risky entreprise for government involvement
3) Government should be concentrating on the areas it is duty bound to provide - affordable/social housing, a hospital and education facilities. Such a premium. public owned site could perceivably be put to much better use, with better social, cultural and even economic returns.
------------
THE STATES are asked to decide whether they are of opinion −
(a) to request the Minister for Treasury and Resources to give directions
to the States of Jersey Development Company Limited in accordance
with Article 22(a) of the Articles of Association of the company that
no binding agreements should be entered into by the company for the
development of new office accommodation on the site known as the
Esplanade Quarter, St. Helier, and no preparatory building works
should be started, until the Corporate Services Scrutiny Panel has
presented to the States the final report arising from its current scrutiny
review of the project;
(b) to agree that, following the presentation of the scrutiny report referred
to in paragraph (a), no agreements for development of office
accommodation on the site should be entered into, and no preparatory
building works should be started, unless the development proposals in
question have been approved by the majority of those voting in a
referendum held under the Referendum (Jersey) Law 2002, and to
request the Minister to give further directions to this effect to the
company.
REPORT
Land in Jersey is a scarce and valuable resource. Whilst the majority of the Public may
remain apathetic or disengaged from mainstream politics, the issues of planning and
land-use remain hot topics in terms of interest and engagement – Plémont and Port
Galôts are just 2 recent examples of this. In the last example, it was public opinion and
pressure that caused a government to rethink its plans for that development, instead of
charging ahead regardless.
I believe it is important that any significant developments, particularly when they
involve risk, need to have public buy-in. I do not believe that what is being proposed
for the office development at the so-called business quarter has that.
But aside from public opinion, there are other good reasons why we might want to
reconsider our plans for this part of the Waterfront.
When it comes to planning and building on the waterfront area, the States of Jersey
does not have a great track record. After all, we closed down a successful and popular
swimming pool only to open up a less popular, less successful – privately run, heavily subsidised
alternative. Many have commented that the buildings and brands on the
current waterfront are generic, and not the best use of the site.
Criticism, scepticism and questioning of the viability and desirability of the proposed
Esplanade Quarter (Jersey Business Centre) is understandably prevalent across Jersey
society and the spectrum of political thought, which is partly what has set alarm bells
ringing.
There are those who do not believe that government should be engaging in State
Capitalism – full stop. There are others, like myself, who are open to these kind of
socialist initiatives, but only if they can be proven to work, provide a social, cultural
need, as well as being economically viable, to bring a return to the taxpayer.
There are 2 key questions to ask: is the scheme viable? Is the scheme desirable?
On the first, it should be noted that there is a scrutiny review going on at the moment
which will hopefully shed some light onto this area. We should certainly await the
outcome of this, and use it to inform any debate on the merits of scheme. But it should
be noted that there is already a brand new and extensive office complex being built
now, privately, next to the Grand Hotel. This is in the vicinity of what has organically
become Jersey’s Business Quarter. It is in the advanced stages of development; it will
be ready much before our new building, and there is a suggestion that, on completion,
it may not be fully rented out.
So, the question remains: why are we competing with the private sector for the
provision of office space, especially when there already appear to be others taking care
of things on the supply side? If no-one else were building offices, maybe we would be
justified in this speculative venture, but this is not the case.
Now, on the second question, is it desirable?
Well, it seems to me that, valid political differences aside, there are some things we
can all agree on at a basic level: it is the role of government to provide basic
infrastructure – schools, hospitals, roads, etc. There are things over and above that which government is bound to have regard and/or where government is best placed to
provide for. Such things are social and affordable housing (Article 25 of the
UN declaration on Human Rights makes it clear that everyone should have the right to
a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his
family, including: housing).